You are in > Home > SAC Consulting > Consultancy Services > Consultancy Services F - H > Farm Diversification > Diversification Database > Archive > Shellfish

Shellfish

This information is from a past project and whilst it is outdated it may still be a viable diversification option under the correct circumstances.

General

There are approximately 185 registered Scottish shellfish farming companies (the number of farms producing shellfish for sale in 2001 is about 97 - from a peak of 173 in 1990).

Most suitable sites are found in the West Coast of Scotland, the Hebrides, Orkney and Shetland.

Operational sites range in size from very small-scale to large-scale commercial units. The most commonly farmed shellfish in Scotland are the common mussel (Mytilus edulis), scallops (both the King scallop Pecten maximus and the Queen Scallop Chlamys opercularis) and oysters - the Pacific Crassostrea gigas and less frequently the native Ostrea edulis.

There are many other edible shellfish, a number of which it would be possible to cultivate. However, few of them are likely to become economic alternatives in the near future.

Manila clams (Tapes semi-decussatus) are being farmed experimentally and there is also interest in lobster (Homarus gammarus).

In 2001 2,988 tonnes of mussels were produced in Scotland, 279 tonnes of Pacific oysters, 47 tonnes of queens, 28 tonnes of scallops and only 8 tonnes of native oyster.

Please remember that special consideration must be given to the VAT aspects of diversification as the new activity may not be treated the same as the existing farm business from a VAT standpoint.

Market

The markets for shellfish are variable, but King scallops have the best prospects, both in the UK and Europe.

Growth areas have been in the catering sector and recipe dishes. there is still relatively low consumption in the UK (partly due to lack of familiarity in how to prepare and cook them).

Most of the exports go to Europe with France being the largest market for Scallops and fresh adn frozen produce being exported to Holland, Italy, Belgium, Spain and Germany. Can sell direct to wholesalers or fishmongers or directly to hotels and restaurants.

Food processors and manufacturers may also purchase shellfish - but consistency and quantity of supply is essential.

Physical Requirements

It is important that people contemplating a shellfish venture are aware of the significant lead time necessary for site research and for growing mollusc to market size.

The following must be considered when selecting a suitable site location - water temperature and quality; salinity (especially scallops); tidal flows; phytoplankton availability; shelter from wind and wave; predators; seabed depth (especially shore-based operations); ease of access and availability of landing sites; free from industrial and waste contamination. Spat Source.

Equipment - dependent on shellfish and system being used.

  • Mussels - the most common method in Scotland is suspended culture from rafts or longlines. Growing period approximately 2 - 3 years.
  • Scallops - suspended culture either in the traditional system of pearl nets and lantern or ear hanging is now being used for King scallops over 40 mm in shell height. Growing period approximately 3 - 5 years (Kings), 2 - 2.5 years (Queens) and 18 months (Princesses).
  • Oysters - either on the shore or submerged. They are contained in plastic trays or bags. Growing period approximately 2 - 4 years.
  • Labour - dependent on level of mechanisation and scale of enterprise can be worked on a part-time basis.

Costs

The following costing information is general and current prices should be sought for budgeting purposes.

Capital Costs

Very variable.

Mussels - rafts or longlines, moorings, mussel ropes, boat, lifting gear, declumper and grader. Small-scale, 5(100m double) headlines or 5 rafts: £34,000 - £38,000.

Scallops - longlines, moorings, spat collectors, pearl nets and lanterns. Small-scale 4(200m) longlines for Kings and Princesses: £30,400 - £34,000.

Oysters - Intertidal unit: trestles and bags, seed and part-grown stock. Small-scale 50,000 per annum: £22,500. Midwater unit: stands and trays, boat, seed and part-grown stock. Small-scale 50,000 per annum: £28,000.

Running Costs

Sea-bed lease from Crown Estate:
oysters: £1.50 - £3.00 per 1,000
mussels: £8 - £16 per tonne

Labour
oysters: 1.5 - 2 man days per 1,000 / annum
mussels: ~8 man days per tonne produced / annum

See oysters 10g seed @ £48 per 1,000 or 12mm seed @ £25 per 1,000 Also fuel, repairs, mussel nets, etc.

Returns

Mussels: about 2 kg per metre mussel rope after 2-3 years @ £700 - £1,300/tonne (depends if wholesale or retail)

Oysters: about 880 oysters from 1,000 10g seed after 1.5 to 3.5 years (or 700 from 1,000 12mm seed after 3-5 years) @ 15 - 25p each.

Scallops 50p each.

Queens 60p each.

The profitability of mussel and oyster production varies widely between different businesses. As mentioned above, the poor market conditions have reduced the number of profitable mussel businesses to a few of the lower cost businesses.

Oyster production has shown steadier profitability, but all shellfish production is relatively labour intensive and even profitable ventures do not generally show a high level of return for the total labour input.

Constraints

Several legal requirements to be considered:

  • Consent from the Crown Estate Commission to farm or harvest oysters, mussels and several other shellfish, and sea bed and sea shore leases are required for the areas you intend to use.
  • A works licence from the local authority if you are in Shetland, and in much of Orkney.
  • All shellfish farms must register with the Scottish Government under The Registration of Fish Farming and Shellfish Farming Businesses Amendment (Scotland) Order 2002 Onshore developments may require planning permission from the Local Authority.
  • Production and sales of live bivalve mussels will come under EC legislation w.e.f. 1/1/93.

The site is all-important and if poor growth is obtained there is little point in persevering. A trial is recommended.

Training

SAC Aberdeen - MSc / Dip. in Aquaculture Business Management Barony College, Parkgate, Dumfries DG1 3NE Tel: 01387 861251 Fax: 01387 860395 (HND, HNC, Cert. in Fisheries Studies, SVQ level 2 Fish Husbandry, Short Courses).

Stirling University - Institute of Aquaculture (MSc Aquaculture, MSc Aquatic Pathobiology, MSc Aquatic Vet Studies, BSc (hons) Aquaculture, short courses, specialist technical training).

Inverness College / Seafield Centre, Kishorn, Strathcarron, Ross-shire IV54 8XD, Tel: 01520 733 300, Fax: 01520 733262 (HNC Fish Farm Production Management, NC Fish Farming, SVQ II Fish Husbandry - distance learning, SVQ III Fish Husbandry, IT computing courses, short courses).

Institute of Fisheries Management, 31 Ferndene, Bradley Stoke, Bristol BS12 9DG, Tel: 01454 624367, Fax: 01454 624033, (Certificates in: Fish Farming, Fisheries Management, Diploma, all by correspondence).

North Atlantic Fisheries College, Port Arthur, Scalloway, Shetland ZE1 0UN Tel: 01595 880328 Fax: 01595 880549 e-mail admin@nafc.ac.uk (MSc/ PGDip Practical Mariculutre, MSc/PGDip. Fisheries Science & Technology, MSc/PGDip. Seafood Science & Technology, HNC Fish Farm Production Management, HNC Fisheries Science & Technology, Modern Apprenticeship in Fish Farming, SVQ Level II Fin Fish Husbandry, SVQ Level II-IV Fishing, NC Marine Science & Technology, Boatmaster's Licence).

Scottish Aquaculture Training Association, contact Mr. John Haig, Old Schoolhouse, Kishorn, Wester Ross, IV54 8XA Tel: 01520 733 452 Fax: 01520 733 452. The SSATA was formed in the early 1990s with the objective of improving the standards and relevance of training provision to the aquaculture industry. With support from the trade associations they aim to ensure that all levels of the industry are aware of the training opportunities which exist, and the resulting benefits. Several courses are co-ordinated by SATA, and others can be arranged. SATA undertake training needs evaluations and provide advice on specific training requirements, especially with regard to Scottish Vocational Qualifications (SVQs).

Grants

Through the Scottish Rural Development Programme (SRDP) 2007-2013 funding is now available for rural businesses throughout Scotland for diversification and renewable energy projects. Specifically, support is delivered through Rural Development Contracts – Rural Priorities which was launched in April 2008. For further information about what support is available see the Section on Rural Development Contracts – Rural Priorities.

Further Information

Publications

Scottish Shellfish Farm Production Survey 2001.

Shellfish Production in Scotland 2000

Shellfish Cultivation in the UK – The Way Forward Dr. Nick Lake

Aquaculture in Scotland. This Newsletter is intended to provide a quick reference to the latest developments on aquaculture in Scotland. It contains economic, statistical, fish-health and environment and planning information, as well as relevant publications and links to other useful web-sites.

Recent studies in King scallop cultivation (2001) (PDF 0.6MB) I. Laing.

Shellfish News. CEFAS Lowestoft, 12: 21-22 Shellfish News Editor - I. Laing - published May and November

The hatchery rearing of King scallops (Pecten maximus) (1997) P.F. Millican General Series, CEFAS Lowestoft.

Bivalve cultivation: criteria for selecting a site Laing and B.E. Spencer

Clam cultivation: Localised environmental effects. Results of an experiment in the River Exe, Devon (1991-1995) B.E. Spencer

Cultivation of Manila clams (1991) (PDF 2.6MB) B.E. Spencer, D.B. Edwards and P.F. Millican Environmental impacts of bivalve mariculture (1998) M.J. Kaiser, I. Laing, S.D. Utting and G.M. Burnell.

Journal of Shellfish Research, 17(1): 59-66 Introduction of marine bivalve molluscs into the UK for commercial culture-case histories (1992)

S.D. Utting and B.E. Spencer ICES Marine Science Symposium, 194: 84-91 See Landsman's Bookshop Ltd's Fish Farming Section

Contact

Mr Steven Thomson
SAC (Scottish Agricultural College) Work SAC, King's Buildings, West Mains Road,
Edinburgh
EH9 3JG

TelWork 0131 535 4192

Add to Address Book | Help